Many entertainment enthusiasts struggle to find trustworthy and nuanced reviews for movies and video games. While platforms like Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic aggregate critic scores, they often reduce complex opinions to a single rating, making it hard for users to discover critics whose tastes align with their own. Meanwhile, individual critics' work is scattered across blogs, magazines, and YouTube, creating a gap for a tool that centralizes and personalizes critical perspectives.

A Search Engine for Critics, Not Just Scores

One way to solve this could be a specialized search engine that indexes reviews from professional and semi-professional critics. Instead of focusing on aggregated scores, this platform would emphasize the critics themselves, allowing users to:

• Search for a specific movie or game and see all critic reviews, sorted by relevance or personal taste alignment.
• Explore detailed critic profiles showcasing their review history, biases (e.g., "prefers indie films"), and rating patterns.
• Get meta-analysis of reviews, such as consensus themes (e.g., "Most critics praised the gameplay but criticized the pacing").

Users could also follow critics they trust, rate reviews as helpful, and receive recommendations based on their preferences. This approach shifts the focus from scores to voices, giving lesser-known critics visibility while helping users build long-term relationships with reviewers they value.

Execution and Differentiation

An MVP could start with a manually curated directory of about 100 critics, offering basic search and profile features. Later phases might include automated review indexing via APIs, sentiment analysis, and personalized recommendations. Unlike existing aggregators, this idea would combine movies and games—two often-overlapping enthusiast communities—while prioritizing qualitative analysis over numerical scores. Key advantages could include:

• Critic-centric design, where individual voices are highlighted rather than buried in averages.
• Cross-medium coverage, appealing to fans of both movies and games.
• Community-driven features (e.g., following critics) to foster engagement.

Potential revenue streams might include affiliate links, premium subscriptions for ad-free browsing, and sponsored placements (clearly labeled). By catering to a niche of discerning enthusiasts, this approach could fill a gap left by one-size-fits-all review aggregators.