The current video game adaptations of J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth largely miss the mark for fans seeking a deep role-playing experience that remains faithful to the source material. While some existing games offer action-packed adventures, there appears to be an untapped opportunity to create a narrative-driven RPG that truly honors Tolkien's intricate worldbuilding and storytelling.

A Lore-Faithful Roleplaying Experience

One approach could be developing a single-player RPG set in Middle-earth's Third Age that focuses on original stories complementing rather than contradicting established canon. Players might create custom characters from Tolkien's races (Men, Elves, Dwarves or Hobbits) and experience morally complex quests with lasting consequences. The gameplay could emphasize:

• Worldbuilding directly drawn from Tolkien's writings
• Multiple solutions to conflicts through dialogue and skill checks
• Organic skill progression based on in-game actions
• Immersive travel mechanics that discourage excessive fast travel

Balancing Authenticity with Engagement

The biggest challenge would be maintaining strict lore accuracy while delivering engaging gameplay. One way this could be addressed is by employing Tolkien scholars as consultants and limiting major canonical character appearances to environmental storytelling. For progression systems, rather than traditional classes, skills could improve through use - becoming more accurate with bows by practicing archery, for example - creating natural character development.

Potential Development Strategy

An incremental approach might involve:

1. Creating a prototype focusing on one region with about 10 hours of content
2. Developing core RPG systems and multi-path quests as proof of concept
3. Expanding to a full game with 3-5 regions after validating the approach

Unlike existing Middle-earth games that prioritize action, this concept could appeal particularly to Tolkien enthusiasts and traditional RPG fans by emphasizing the world's languages, cultures, and moral philosophy through player choice and exploration rather than combat.